| Rank | Michael Farradae | Ben Poprocky | Justin Shaffer | |
| #1 | Yuengling Black and Tan (8.7) | Pabst Blue Ribbon Lager (∞) | Yuengling Lager (8.8) | |
| #2 | Central Water's Brewhouse Coffee Stout (8.3) | Brooklyn Pennant Ale '55 (8.6) | Peak Brewing Company IPA
(8.25)
| |
| #3 | Goose Island Brewery's Harvest Ale (7.8) | Dogfish Head Burton Baton (6.8) | Stone Brewery's Pale Ale
(8.0)
| |
| #4 | New Belgium Shift Pale Lager (7.8) | Straub Brewery's Premium Lager (6.8) | Magic Hat #9 (not so pale ale)
(8.0)
| |
| #5 | Harpoon UFO White Hefeweissen (7.3) | Great Lakes Brewing Co. Commodore Perry (6.7) | Peak Brewing Company Pale Ale
(7.5)
|
| Rank | Brendon Radcliffe | Nick Mastrian | Andrew Tarr | |
| #1 | Founders Centennial IPA (8.8) | North Country Brewing - Breakfast Blend Mild (8.25) | Flying Dog Brewery's Doggie Style Classic Pale Ale (9.8) | |
| #2 | Yard's Brawler Pugilist Ale (8.3) | 21st Amendment Brewery – Back In Black (7.5) | Great Lakes Brewing Co.'s Eliot Ness (8.5) | |
| #3 | Stoudt's Scarlet Lady ESB (7.0) | 21st Amendment Brewery - Brew Free or Die IPA (7.3) | Rogue Ales Juniper Pale Ale
(8.3)
| |
| #4 | Samuel Smith Oatmeal Stout (7.0) | 21st Amendment Brewery - Hell or High Watermelon Wheat Beer (6.6) | Flying Dog Brewery - UnderDog Atlantic Lager (8.3) | |
| #5 | Bell's Kalamazoo Stout (5.5) | Sierra Nevada - Bigfoot Ale (6.5) | Red Dog Beer (7.5) |
